Saturday, December 19, 2009

AVATAR and Lacking Truth in Science Fiction

When it comes to science fiction, I can do a fair job of removing myself from the contemporary politics and other rattlings in culture that it is supposed to be referencing and attempting to indoctrinate me in so that I can just enjoy a good yarn. I went to see AVATAR with the same thing in mind. I knew what I was stepping into, much of which is described in the post below, but I prepared myself and decided I would just enjoy the story.

http://bighollywood.breitbart.com/bighollywood/2009/12/18/avatar-contrarian-round-up-the-king-of-the-world-is-naked/

Now the Big Environmental Message, I was like ... whatever. The "Gaia" story has been part of the Science Fiction genre since its inception. Nothing new there and so I had less of a problem with it. I know that Cameron is trying to sell me a bill of goods about global warming and how evil we are ... but being way overly-read in the science fiction genre, it was easy to just fold it into the Gaia Science Fiction category (granted it doesn't hold a candle to Asimov's take on that at the end of the Foundation series ... but I digress into my geekiness).

Here was the real problem for me. In probably the most emotional part of the film as the Marines (and they are US Marines ... they are not some meta-Earth-United type military group) essentially commit a massacre on a huge scale (and also on a personal scale in that its not like they're off in a bunker and hit a button and somewhere some people die ... they're there on the ground personally doing it) of sentient, humanoid (and generally human looking ... in other words an alien one can relate to) natives, one is supposed to believe the scenario. But here is where the film failed completely for me. I am supposed to believe that a bunch of US Marines raised vaguely (although the year is not really defined) somewhere in the 21st century, having been raised in an America where not only is there the unique story of our own relationship to the Native Americans but we also have been surrounded by stories like Dances With Wolves, etc etc ... Marines trained not only in warfare but being able to recognize who the enemy is (the Jarheads in other words are not mindless guns) ... I am supposed to believe that they would sit there and through the course of the film commit genocide willingly ... fully understanding what they are doing? That just strikes me as unbelieveable. The genius of any good science fiction is that it has beneath the fanciful the possibility for truth. Its what makes it so fascinating. But to believe that a group of 21st century American Marines, characters we can recognize and relate to culturally as they are not far enough removed from contemporary real Marines, would be so willing to commit genocide both physically and culturally (there is a real Taliban-destroying-cultural-monuments moment in the movie except its the Marines doing it) just feels false. From that first massacre on, I just could not relate to the movie at all anymore ... it moved beyond Science Fiction into just a poorly written story based on no truth whatsoever (that seed of truth being the hallmark of any good science fiction).

Was it a visually stunning 2 1/2 hour adventure? Yes. But in the end it was just intellectually and emotionally insulting. I was able to successfully divorce myself from today's politics in order to enjoy the movie (it was a conscious effort on my part) ... but all that came to a crashing end when I was supposed to "suspend my disbelief" at the concept of relatively contemporary American Marines willfully committing genocide. I honestly think this part of the movie is the one people should be complaining about the most.

37 comments:

電話 said...

When everything is coming your way, you are in the wrong lane.............................................

控制 said...

春宮性愛教學taiwan sex大奶子台灣情色論壇台灣av女優一夜情留言板女生裸體色情電話a網情色片美女裸照成人笑話巨乳學院裸體寫真av寫真走光照巨奶做愛技巧a圖片淫亂撫摸情色聊天少婦自拍淫娃一夜情聊天av情色本土av女生高潮色情av成人情色貼圖一夜情留言成人圖庫亞洲成人口交技巧性經驗成人18三點全露蕩婦情色自拍貼圖成人漫畫成人漫畫

美麗 said...

每個人生命中都可能遇到貴人,這些貴人不一定真的尊貴,他可能是陌生人,也可能是你的敵人。 ..................................................

玉鳳 said...

It may be that your sole purpose in life is simply to serve as a warning to others.............................................

明偉誠秋 said...

你可以從外表的美來評論一朵花或一隻蝴蝶,但你不能這樣來評論一個人........................................

羅惠玲 said...

唯有用熱情、用智慧去觀察事物,這事物才會把他的秘密,洩漏給我們......................................................

劉WileyMares said...

Nice Post~!!!. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

BertR25596 said...

Nice Post~!!!. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

淑慧 said...

It's great!!............................................................

90809eugeniopals said...

人是受想像力所支配的。........................................

meSTarr said...

Are you kidding me? You don't think people are capable of doing such a thing? Look at our history! Look at how we got to America! You think we didn't look the Natives right in the eye and then clear them out of their own home? You are blind, then, and that is so sad for the people who are actually experiencing this RIGHT NOW on our planet. People - not civilized - who want no part in this life, but are forced to drink our polluted water & breath polluted air that they haave nothing to do with. Open you eyes, buddy! We ARE those people!

FrederickBove98787 said...

唯有穿鞋的人,才知道鞋的哪一處擠腳...............................................................

EdwardG_Burrell1016 said...

一句話,那就是,"船到橋頭自然直.".............................................

M12aeganT_Moe12 said...

kk視訊內衣秀 免費情色av影片 情色小魔女自拍 免費情色影片無碼 qq美美色網免費看 ut辣妹哈啦視訊聊天室 34c美女寶貝視訊 ez聊天網 avdvd成人影城 aa台辣妹有約 34c玩美女人百分百貼影片區 一葉情貼圖片區 383 天下貼圖情趣 商品 一對多視訊大學生情人 gogo2sex視訊妹 線上免費視訊聊天 yam天空辣妹影音 視訊交友etude 比基尼辣妹 kk272視訊 A片-sex520 影音聊天室fm358 sex520 net視訊美女 080視訊聊天室how2 85st免費影片觀看 小弟弟成人娛樂網 辣妹視訊聊天室 90691 免費熟女人影片 g8mm 視訊小愛 比基尼美女的奶,玩美女人影音秀 383影音城a 情色視訊,貓貓論壇 啦咧華人視訊交友聊天室 38ga成人 辣妹有約溫泉 微風愛情館論壇aio 我愛78論壇影片 飯島愛免費影片 辣手美眉甜心寶貝直播貼片 免費a片觀看 視訊交友loveliness av影片下載 avhigh免費影片 限制性影片 hi5 tv 免費聊天情人fm358 a383girl影音城 亞洲視訊34c甜心寶貝直播貼片 免費聊天mmshow 南台灣視訊網愛聊天室

展姍展姍 said...

生存乃是不斷地在內心與靈魂交戰;寫作是坐著審判自己。...........................................................................

walsha said...

The shortest answer is doing. ............................................................

俊翔 said...

線上免費成人觀賞 視訊 摸摸耳聊天 免費av 視訊交友網 女優 性感寶貝 成人影片交流 偷拍性交 ut色情聊天室 女人愛愛 情趣 同志18禁 少女裸睡 aa洪爺影城 a片面 情色守門員 麗的色情小戲 一夜情 383影音live秀 影音視訊 玩美女人試看 美女女優寫真 辣妹自拍貼圖網 人妻線上看 免費影片 77p2p 85街 a圖網a圖貼圖 美女寫真 85cc+ 免費成人 85st 視訊聊天 貼圖區 援交 情人視訊 免費脫衣秀 dvd av女優 洪爺影城下載區 大奶影片 sex888貼圖區 170部a下載 日本巨乳a片 百性線上直播網 後宮電影院長 限制級視訊 0204視訊美女 免費性愛片 正妹日報

奕生 said...

來給你加油打氣!!!保重!!! .................................................................

劉彥皓 said...

感謝您費心的分享您的生活!讓我也感同身受!

姿吟姿吟 said...

成熟,就是有能力適應生活中的模糊。....................................................................

佩春 said...

閒來無聊逛逛blog~~跟您打聲招呼~~.................................................................

于庭 said...

成熟,就是有能力適應生活中的模糊。.................................................................

王名仁 said...

It takes all kinds to make a world.............................................................

雅芳 said...

Some people cannot see the wood for the trees.............................................................

柏強 said...

原來天鵝嫁給癩蛤蟆就會生出醜小鴨。。。............................................................

1986/6/7 said...

晚上好,很喜歡你的blog哦...............................................................

蔡舜娟蔡舜娟 said...

一棵樹除非在春天開了花,否則難望在秋天結果。..................................................

陳韋夏陳韋夏益東富益東富 said...

Many a true word is spoken in jest..................................................................

蔡舜娟蔡舜娟 said...

第一忠誠,第二勤奮,第三專心工作。..................................................

韓秀美 said...

感謝您寫下您的生活,也是把珍寶來和諸君分享的心意。 ............................................................

施以王雅玲音 said...

百發百中不是一試就成的。.......................................................

柏鈺苓俐 said...

良言一句三冬暖,惡語傷人六月寒。......................................................................

文王廷 said...

大師手筆﹐果然不凡..................................................................

璇陳陳陳竹 said...

所有的資產,在不被諒解時,都成了負債............................. ....................................

瑰潼 said...

人有兩眼一舌,是為了觀察倍於說話的緣故。............................................................

黃怡君 said...

我來湊熱鬧的~~^^ 要平安快樂哦..................................................

王雅俊 said...

到處逛逛~~來繞繞留個言囉~~~~............................................................